International development and finance

Evaluation of Finnfund: The Finnish Fund for Industrial Cooperation Ltd.

Finnfund is a bilateral development finance institution (DFI) which provides finance to firms in developing countries, to promote social, environmental and economic development. This evaluation of Finnfund was led by Just Economics staff. It was commissioned by the Finnish Ministry of Foreign Affairs and conducted in partnership with Partcip GmbH. 

The goals of this evaluation were to assess Finnfund’s historical performance, the extent to which it has followed its mandate and annual guidance, and the likelihood that the 2018-2025 strategy will achieve its objectives. Phase 1 reviewed Finnfund’s record on development impact, and alignment with its mandate. Phase 2 appraised the future strategy based on fieldwork in three countries in Latin America and Africa.

Download 2
Forest

In the ex-post study, the evaluation found that Finnfund was broadly consistent with annual guidance and best practice in both commercial and environmental/social risk management, and often exceeded these.

While it is not possible to assess causality, we find evidence of job creation on the part of investees, as well as improved business performance. Findings on taxation are inconclusive. Finnfund’s country and sector allocations also suggest that impacts are being achieved, if not always captured. On additionality, we find that Finnfund’s investments are most likely to be additional in forestry and agriculture. 

The fieldwork found some evidence for positive outcomes in areas such as capacity development, business performance, the scale and quality of employment, and community and environmental impacts. We cannot
generalise from this to the portfolio, however, due to the small sample size. The evaluation finds that the goal of tripling impact is only possible if the trend towards high impact countries and sectors continues, but that this is likely to increase risks and lower returns. Ensuring that Finnfund expands in a way that is compatible with this is essential. We set out a number of ways this could be done, which entail different combinations of public and private investment, and potential changes in key areas such as Finnfund’s return requirements. Finally, to increase impact on the scale required, Finnfund needs a greater on-the-ground presence in the countries in which it operates, and to engage closely with investees to better performance. Just as importantly, impacts need to be robustly measured and reported. Finnfund needs the support of public opinion in Finland, providing credible evidence of impact, and engaging actively in development policy circles, is key to this.

Related projects

Iied Case Study Image
Principles of socially-responsible investment

How can investors be encouraged to consider more than purely commercial and short-term gains? Various sets of investment principles have emerged in recent years to guide socially responsible investment. These principles aim to incorporate social, environmental and governance criteria into investment decisions in order to enhance the benefits and reduce the damaging effects of investment for development. This review for IIED takes a first step in assessing the content, take-up, implementation and impact of the four main sets of principles for socially-responsible investment.

Iied Case Study Banner
Evaluation of the Nordic Development Bank

The Nordic Development Fund (NDF) is the joint development finance institution of the five Nordic countries. The objective of NDF's operations is to facilitate climate change investments primarily in low-income countries.  This project seeks to assess whether the NDF's activities are consistent with its mandate and evaluate the extent to which its investments are having positive impacts to inform its future strategy. The evaluation has been commissioend by EBA, the Expert Group on Aid and is being conducted in partnership with Particp GmbH. The evaluation will conclude in Spring 2019.

Focus areas

Our client base ranges from local charities to public sector bodies and global corporates. We apply our expertise to key focus areas that our team are passionate about.

Who we work with

Client Logo The Scottish Government
Client Logo Itad
Client Logo British Telecoms
Client Logo Ucd
Client Logo Microsoft
Client Logo Cabinet Office
Client Logo Living Streets
Client Logo Amnestry International
Client Logo University Of Maynooth
Client Logo Focus Ireland
Client Logo Womens Budget Group
Client Jamie Oliver Foundation
Client Logo Bookstart
Client Logo Football Foundation
Client Logo Cafod
Client Logo Iied
Lra Logo Ni